There is a social cooling that does not look like silence from the inside. People keep talking. Books move. Interviews circulate. A language of anxiety, loneliness, agency, burnout, attention, and the nearby still finds channels. The air is not empty. It lacks the public room where speech can harden into record, organization, and leverage.

That is the uncomfortable split in David Ownby’s recent material at Reading the China Dream. His introduction to Xu Jilin’s interview, “Those Born in the 1990s and 2000s No Longer Believe in Great Narratives” , describes a public intellectual space that opened during reform and opening and is now disappearing; the interview itself was taken down shortly after publication. Xu is not presented as a dissident hero striking a pose. The mood is sadder and more precise: a type of public intellectual work has lost its room. Influencer formats, short videos, media cocoons, and ideological discipline do not simply censor an old class of speakers. They change where speech can appear.